Do a 360 Check
The dress fit perfectly, however, I should've inspected the entire dress before cutting the tag. There were quite a few black oil stains (at least 8) on the bottom back and I wasn't able to return it. Shouldn't have assumed it wouldn't have black stains on it when it arrived in a sealed plastic bag.
Response from Lulus.com:
Hi Christina! We are so sorry to hear that you received this dress in such a condition. This is not at all a typical experience and we'd love to take care of this for you! Please keep an eye out for an email from our Customer Care team. We'll be in touch soon! xo