Ordered wrong size
I should have ordered 1/2 size up. I returned. I ended up getting some that looked very similar at target.
Response from Lulus.com:
Hello Analese! We're sorry to hear that these pumps fit smaller than you expected. If you would like additional insight regarding sizing for future purchases, please reach out to our team of fit experts (lulus.com/customerservice). We want to help you shop with confidence! Thanks for your review! xo