Straps are too long
The straps are way too long, but since I bought this on sale and it fit otherwise, I ended up cutting the straps shorter and remade a new hole so it fit around my ankles.
Response from Lulus.com:
Hi Kat, thank you for sharing your feedback with us! We're sorry to hear that the straps were too long for you. We want you to love every Lulus purchase, so if you are ever in need, please get in touch with us (lulus.com/customerservice). We would be happy to help! xo